Report a maintenance issue
If you’re facing a dispute about property – maybe a boundary disagreement with a neighbour, unexpected structural damage in a house you’ve recently bought, or a building job that’s gone wrong – where do you turn? You know something isn’t right. But how do you prove it? Who will the court listen to?
If you suspect something is wrong with your home, the last thing you want to do is throw good money after bad, which is why it’s so important to take the right next steps. What you need is clear, independent evidence from someone that the legal system will find credible. That’s where an Expert Witness Survey comes in.
Formal evidence that is submitted by a reliable source is worth its weight in gold in any legal battle. If you’re involved in a property dispute and need to make your case, an Expert Witness Survey could be the document that influences the final decision.
What Is an Expert Witness Survey?
An Expert Witness Survey is a detailed and impartial report that is created by a qualified professional, usually a chartered surveyor. It’s specifically produced for legal proceedings to convey independent, expert evidence about a property dispute to the decision makers in a court or tribunal.
The report has to be prepared in line with Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) Part 35, which sets out the criteria for how evidence can be used in civil court cases within England and Wales. The Survey will not only include observations, but also professional opinion based on qualifications, experience and any relevant industry standards.
It’s important to note that the purpose of the Survey isn’t to support one party, but to offer a balanced, informed view that can help the court reach its decision. You commissioning the Survey doesn’t necessarily mean that its findings will support your case.
When Would You Need an Expert Witness Survey?
Most people don’t expect to find themselves in court over a property dispute, but issues arise more often than you might think. When they do, having professional input is invaluable.
Common Property Disputes That Require An Expert Witness Survey
- Boundary disagreements
It’s incredibly common for neighbours to disagree on where one property ends and the other begins. If you’re arguing over boundary lines or believe that a fence, hedge, outbuilding or extension is encroaching on your property, an Expert Witness Surveyor may be able to shed light.
- Structural defects
If you’ve purchased a house and later found signs of subsidence or structural issues that weren’t declared, it’s definitely worth consulting an Expert Witness Land Surveyor. They can help determine whether an issue is historic or recent, and whether there’s any sign that it was intentionally hidden.
- Valuation disputes
Disagreement over property value is an issue that often comes up in marriage dissolutions or commercial matters where both parties have differing opinions on the market value of a property. For an impartial valuation that could be relied on in court, an Expert Witness Survey is a good investment.
- Party wall issues
If construction has impacted a shared wall or adjoining structure, expert input can clarify what level of damage has occurred and by which party.
- Building work gone wrong
A problem that nobody wants to experience, but many will, poor workmanship or non-compliance with regulations can be the start of a long legal battle. An Expert Witness Survey gives you the confidence of a professional deeming whether work was done to a ‘reasonable standard’.
Leicester Expert Witness Survey Saves Client Time, Money and Stress
A Leicester homeowner approached us after discovering cracks in their property following construction work on their neighbours’ extension. The neighbour denied responsibility, saying there was no proof that the cracks had been caused by the building work and could have been pre-existing. A standard survey was inconclusive, so the team at Readings Property Group were brought in to conduct an Expert Witness Survey.
Our report found that the damage was consistent with recent foundation movement caused by nearby excavation. The report was accepted by both parties and used in mediation to reach a fair financial settlement, saving the client a lengthy court case.
Expert Witness vs Standard Survey – What’s the Difference?
As demonstrated in the case study above, a Standard Survey and an Expert Witness Survey can have different findings. It’s understandable to want to start with the cheaper option, but by picking the right survey for your situation from the outset, you reduce your risk of having to pay twice.
Key Differences Between Survey Types
- Purpose
A Standard Survey is for your personal use and can help inform you about the condition of a property before you purchase it. An Expert Witness Survey is specifically for use as legal evidence.
- Format
Standard Surveys usually follow the same general format, but can differ depending on the nature of the job. Expert Surveys have to follow specific legal formatting, include legal declarations and set out the expert’s qualifications in order for them to be admissible in court.
- Legal standing
As a Standard Survey is not recognised under CPR Part 35, it may not be admissible in court, or if it is, it will carry significantly less weight than the more professional and credible Expert Witness Survey.
- Level of detail
By their very nature, Expert Witness Surveys go a lot deeper than Standard Surveys. As well as providing observations, they go a step further, giving well-reasoned conclusions that are supported with evidence, drawings, photos or technical data.
Who Can Carry Out an Expert Witness Survey?
As you may have gathered, not just anyone can carry out a Witness Survey. To be accepted by the courts, the surveyor should be:
- A RICS qualified professional (Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors)
- Familiar with CPR Part 35 and the court’s requirements for expert reports
- Experienced in the type of property dispute relevant to your query
- Able to act independently and impartially, regardless of who enlisted their services.
If the court has any reason to believe that the Expert Witness Surveyor did not have the experience, professionalism or objectivity to be balanced in their report, it may undermine your case. Remember, a surveyor’s job is not to advocate for you; it’s to provide clear, credible evidence that can stand up to legal scrutiny.
Why Choose Readings Property Group?
When you’re involved in a property dispute, you need more than just a qualified expert, you need someone who understands the local market and the legal process.
Trusted Local Experts in Leicester
At Readings Property Group, our RICS-accredited surveyors have decades of experience in residential or commercial real estate. They’re also fully compliant with CPR Part 35 and have training in the correct preparation of legal reports. And of course, like all of our team, they’re known for their clear communication, attention to detail and ability to be impartial.
Need Advice on a Property Dispute?
If you’re dealing with a property issue and don’t know where to turn, our team is here to help. Based in Leicester, we’ve supported countless clients through property disputes. We’ll talk you through whether an expert witness survey is the right next step, and what’s involved.
Visit our Contact Page or call us to speak directly with one of our surveyors. We’re happy to offer initial guidance without any pressure – just helpful advice when you need it most.
